Journal Published Online: 01 April 1983
Volume 28, Issue 2

Competent and Incompetent Defendants Referred to a Court Psychiatric Clinic: A Clinical Comparison

CODEN: JFSCAS

Abstract

Psychiatric evaluation of a defendant's present state of mind is required by criminal courts whenever the question of competency to proceed in the face of criminal charges is raised. From the examination of court-ordered psychiatric evaluations conducted during a seven-year period, a comparison was made of demographic, clinical, and diagnostic differences between a group of defendants evaluated as incompetent to stand trial and a group evaluated as competent. Findings showed the incompetent defendant to be older, more likely to be female, and more often intellectually impaired. Psychiatric diagnoses revealed more severe symptoms of disabling mental illness and a greater likelihood of psychosis. Because a finding of competency or incompetency dictates different legal dispositions, frequently bringing the legal proceedings to a halt and diverting the defendant into the mental health system, clear behavioral and symptomatic criteria for incompetency to stand trial are needed.

Author Information

Heller, MS
Institute of Law and the Health Sciences, Temple University, Philadelphia, PA
Traylor, WH
Temple University, Philadelphia, PA
Ehrlich, SM
Institute of Law and the Health Sciences, Temple University, Philadelphia, PA
Lester, D
Richard Stockton State College, Pomona, NJ
Pages: 8
Price: $25.00
Related
Reprints and Permissions
Reprints and copyright permissions can be requested through the
Copyright Clearance Center
Details
Stock #: JFS11523J
ISSN: 0022-1198
DOI: 10.1520/JFS11523J