Insulation Draws Water

    Volume 39, Issue 1 (January 2011)

    ISSN: 0090-3973

    CODEN: JTEOAD

    Published Online: 16 August 2010

    Page Count: 12


    Rose, William B.
    Research Architect, Univ. of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Champaign, IL

    (Received 21 January 2010; accepted 14 June 2010)

    Abstract

    In the late 1930s, an architect and two researchers created a version of hygrothermal building science for the United States that focused on moisture conditions in exterior materials during cold weather. The version they created was partial, and it was biased: It highlighted the importance of vapor transport, while it obscured the importance of temperature impact. They based their argument on the prevention of “condensation,” yet they failed to provide a definition of condensation sufficient for use as a performance measure or criterion. They produced prescriptive recommendations that later became code requirements, and these prescriptions embodied the incomplete and biased nature of their analysis. They supported their argument with a flawed and misleading analogy. They and their followers left a legacy of consumer fear of ill-defined moisture effects in buildings and of designers assigning excessive importance to prescriptive measures. Their version provides inadequate preparation for the anticipated re-insulation of millions of U.S. buildings in the years to come. This paper will provide a short description of the hygrothermal issues involved. It will trace the development of the condensation version by Rogers, Teesdale, and Rowley and the efforts that followed up to 1952. It will explain the legacy and impact of this approach related to existing building re-insulation and professional practice in design and architecture. It will propose a framework for reviewing the link between moisture control prescriptive requirements and performance outcomes.


    Paper ID: JTE102972

    DOI: 10.1520/JTE102972

    ASTM International is a member of CrossRef.

    Author
    Title Insulation Draws Water
    Symposium Condensation in Exterior Building Wall Systems, 2010-10-11
    Committee E06