STP840

    Comparison of the Fate and Ecological Effects of Dispersed and Nondispersed Oil in a Variety of Intertidal Habitats

    Published: Jan 1984


      Format Pages Price  
    PDF (524K) 41 $25   ADD TO CART
    Complete Source PDF (6.3M) 41 $59   ADD TO CART


    Abstract

    Field experiments were carried out to compare the littoral fate and ecological effects of chemically dispersed oil and nondispersed oil. The basic experimental design was a series of treatments applied to marked plots on rocky shores, a salt marsh, an intertidal sea-grass bed, and sand and mud flats. The treatments included a variety of oils and the dispersants BP 1100 WD, BP 1100X, Corexit® 8667, and Corexit 7664, applied directly to the intertidal plots. Results from treatments on intertidal rock suggested that oil deposition or oil deposition followed by dispersant cleaning had a greater effect than dispersant cleaning alone on limpets (Patella spp.) and small winkles (Littorina spp.). On the salt marsh, oil or oil followed by dispersant cleaning significantly reduced the density of the perennial grass Spartina anglica C.E. Hubbard and the annual plant Salicornia spp. Dispersant alone had relatively little effect on the vegetation. On the sea-grass bed, although variability was high, all treatments reduced the percentage cover of the sea-grass Zostera noltii Hornem. Sediment hydrocarbon analysis indicated little long-term retention of applied oil (whether dispersant treated or not) in the salt marsh mud and in muddy sand on a waterlogged intertidal flat. However, in the sea-grass bed sediments and in the fine sands on freely draining intertidal flats, dispersant-treated oil was, in some cases, retained at greater concentrations than untreated oil. The results are discussed with reference to the rocky shore Exposure Scale of Ballantine, to the shoreline Vulnerability Index of Gundlach and Hayes, and to factors such as the behavior of the water table, particle size, and depth of disturbance of sediments.

    Keywords:

    oil spill, dispersant, field experiments, rocky shores, salt marsh, sea grass, intertidal sediments


    Author Information:

    Baker, JM
    research directorresearch officerresearch officerdirector of studiessenior tutor, Field Studies CouncilOil Pollution Research UnitField Studies CouncilOrielton Field CentreThe Leonard Wills' Field Centre, Nettlecombe Court, Pembroke, DyfedWilliton, Taunton, Somerset, Wales

    Crothers, JH
    research directorresearch officerresearch officerdirector of studiessenior tutor, Field Studies CouncilOil Pollution Research UnitField Studies CouncilOrielton Field CentreThe Leonard Wills' Field Centre, Nettlecombe Court, Pembroke, DyfedWilliton, Taunton, Somerset, Wales

    Little, DI
    research directorresearch officerresearch officerdirector of studiessenior tutor, Field Studies CouncilOil Pollution Research UnitField Studies CouncilOrielton Field CentreThe Leonard Wills' Field Centre, Nettlecombe Court, Pembroke, DyfedWilliton, Taunton, Somerset, Wales

    Oldham, JH
    research directorresearch officerresearch officerdirector of studiessenior tutor, Field Studies CouncilOil Pollution Research UnitField Studies CouncilOrielton Field CentreThe Leonard Wills' Field Centre, Nettlecombe Court, Pembroke, DyfedWilliton, Taunton, Somerset, Wales

    Wilson, CM
    research directorresearch officerresearch officerdirector of studiessenior tutor, Field Studies CouncilOil Pollution Research UnitField Studies CouncilOrielton Field CentreThe Leonard Wills' Field Centre, Nettlecombe Court, Pembroke, DyfedWilliton, Taunton, Somerset, Wales


    Paper ID: STP30240S

    Committee/Subcommittee: F20.18

    DOI: 10.1520/STP30240S


    CrossRef ASTM International is a member of CrossRef.