STP1075: Report of an Interlaboratory Study Comparing EPA SW 846 Method 3050[1] and an Alternative Method from the California Department of Health Services

    Kimbrough, DE
    Public Health Chemist II, Southern California Laboratory, Los Angeles, CA

    Wakakuwa, J
    Supervising Chemist, Southern California Laboratory, Los Angeles, CA

    Pages: 14    Published: Jan 1991


    Abstract

    The existing EPA method for the analysis of toxic elements in solid matrices, SW 846 method 3050, cannot accurately or precisely determine (i.e., within SW 846 quality control limits) the concentrations of either antimony or silver and can do so for barium only at lower concentrations. An alternative method was developed by the Southern California Laboratory of the Department of Health Services that could (1) simultaneously solubilize all of the above elements over a broader range of concentrations and (2) solubilize all other regulated elements with equal or better results.

    As a part of the validation process for this alternative method, an interlaboratory study was conducted. Nine public and private laboratories compared the existing method with our alternative method. The results of this study clearly show statistically significant differences between method 3050 and the alternative method proposed in this paper.

    Keywords:

    acid digestion, elemental analysis, interlaboratory study, solid waste


    Paper ID: STP25480S

    Committee/Subcommittee: D18.14

    DOI: 10.1520/STP25480S


    CrossRef ASTM International is a member of CrossRef.