STP1338

    Evaluation of the Performance of Statistical Tests Used in Making Cleanup Decisions at Superfund Sites. Part 1: Choosing an Appropriate Statistical Test

    Published: Jan 1998


      Format Pages Price  
    PDF (288K) 16 $25   ADD TO CART
    Complete Source PDF (3.1M) 16 $55   ADD TO CART


    Abstract

    The decision rules commonly employed to determine the need for cleanup (including those cited in recent guidance) are evaluated below both to identify conditions under which they lead to erroneous conclusions and to quantify the rate that such errors occur. Their performance is also compared with that of other applicable decision rules.

    We based the evaluation of decision rules on simulations. Results are presented as power curves. These curves demonstrate that the degree of statistical control achieved is independent of the form of the null hypothesis. The loss of statistical control that occurs when a decision rule is applied to a data set that does not satisfy the rule's validity criteria is also clearly demonstrated. Some of the rules evaluated do not offer the formal statistical control that is an inherent design feature of other rules. Nevertheless, results indicate that such “informal” decision rules may provide superior overall control of error rates, when their application is restricted to data exhibiting particular characteristics.

    The results reported here are limited to decision rules applied to uncensored and lognormally distributed data. To optimize decision rules, it is necessary to evaluate their behavior when applied to data exhibiting a range of characteristics that bracket those common to field data. The performance of decision rules applied to data sets exhibiting a broader range of characteristics is reported in the second paper of this study.

    Keywords:

    risk assessment, site assessment, statistics, decision error, error rates, hypothesis tests, confidence limits


    Author Information:

    Berman, DW
    President, Aeolus Environmental Services, Albany, CA

    Allen, BC
    Project Manager, ICF Kaiser Engineers, Research Triangle Park, NC

    Van Landingham, CB
    Project Manager, ICF Kaiser Engineers, Ruston, LA


    Paper ID: STP13289S

    Committee/Subcommittee: D18.01

    DOI: 10.1520/STP13289S


    CrossRef ASTM International is a member of CrossRef.