Pipeline and Oxygen Expert, Air Liquide, Champigny sur Marne,
Quality Manager CTE, Air Liquide Laboratory, Blanc Mesnil,
Materials Expert, Air Liquide, Paris,
Pages: 19 Published: Jan 2000
The document ASTM G.94.92 “Standard Guide for Evaluating Metals for Oxygen Service ” gives a complete guidance for the selection of metals. The different test methods are explained and a metal ranking table is given for each method. The best-known test is promoted combustion as described in ASTM G.124-95 “ Standard Test Method for Determining the Combustion Behaviour of Metallic Material in Oxygen Enriched Atmospheres ”. In this ranking aluminium bronze with only 9 to 13% aluminium is near aluminium and is therefore considered less resistant than any stainless steel.
This result is not consistent with the paper “ Ignition Testing of Hollow Vessels Pressurised with Gaseous Oxygen ” . The particle impact test performed by NASA as described by Benz, et al  also gives a better ranking for aluminium bronze, between Inconel 600 and 625.
Analysing how ignition occurs in oxygen pipeline networks, we considered that the most probable cause is promoted ignition by particles. New rankings of metals are established in the case of impact on bulk materials by burning particles. Two theoretical rankings are based on interface temperature associated with a critical temperature, while another ranking is based on the results of tests made on the gaseous oxygen impact apparatus, with the addition of particles. Measurements of interface temperatures for different metals confirm the theoretical values. A comparison of the different rankings is discussed for metal selection for oxygen valves and it appears that stainless steel and aluminium bronze with 9 to 11% aluminium are equivalent choices for oxygen valves.
oxygen, oxygen compatibility, ranking of metal, aluminium bronze, valve accidents, interface temperature, critical temperature, hollow vessel, particle impact
Paper ID: STP12486S