Digital Library / STP / STP1431-EB / STP11128S



Relative 3 Dimensional Motions between End Vertebrae in a Bi-level Construct, the Effect of Fixture Constraints on Test Results
Carson WL


Pages: 10    Published: Jan 2003


Download this paper for $25 PDF (248K)          View License Agreement
        Click here to download the complete source publication for $118 PDF (5.0M)


Source: STP1431-EB


Abstract
Bilevel spinal implant constructs are 3 dimensional with 6 degrees-of-freedom of superior relative to inferior vertebra motion. ASTM F 1717-01 pinned fixtures constrain 3 degrees-of-freedom, which for posterior constructs are: lateral translation, PA axis rotation, and axial rotation to be about axis through the center of each vertebral body mounting pin. Also, F 1717-01 only illustrates testing of rectangular constructs that are symmetrical about a mid plane. Clinical examples, unconstrained finite element models, and hand held-loaded models are used to illustrate that in general some of the primary components of construct displacement and modes of failure are those constrained by the fixtures in F 1717-01; with one exception being the axial loading of rectangular constructs that remain symmetrical in geometry and biomechanical characteristics of components and interconnections. This raises two questions: the possibility of some clinical modes of failure being obscured by F 1717-01, and the clinical relevance of some numerical test results. Gimbal-gimbal or pushrod-gimbal fixtures for unconstrained axial and torsional load, static and fatigue testing, unsymmetrical as well as symmetrical constructs is proposed as a replacement for the current pinned fixtures.


Keywords:
Construct, constrained, unconstrained, axial, torsion, F 1717-01

Paper ID: STP11128S
Committee/Subcommittee: F04.25
DOI: 10.1520/STP11128S
CrossRef ASTM International is a member of CrossRef.