Standards

ASTM WK41417

(What is a Work Item? / How to Input to a Work Item)

Work Item: ASTM WK41417 - Revision of A20 / A20M - 11 Standard Specification for General Requirements for Steel Plates for Pressure Vessels


Active Standard: A20 / A20M - 11

Developed by Subcommittee: A01.11 | Committee A01 Home | Contact Staff Manager



1. Rationale

Note 4 in 19.1.1 regards a limit for reporting chemical elements that when analyzed to be 0.02% may be reported as such. This is contained in a section that has nothing to do with chemistry, but more importantly there is a conflict with Table 1 that requires boron to be 0.0010% maximum when it is an unspecified element. Reporting criteria, thus, may be confusing and since the value of 0.02% could be seriously high for boron this needs to be addressed clearly. In addition, the other elements in Table 1, if reported as 0.02% could allow for small intentional additions up to 0.024% when rounded that violate the spirit of the Table. It is proposed to simply remove the note.


Keywords

general delivery requirement; pressure containing parts; pressure vessel steels; steel plates; steel plates for pressure vessel applications; Alloy steel plate--specifications; General delivery requirements--steel; Pressure vessel steel plate--specifications; Steel plate--specifications;

Citing ASTM Standards

[Back to Top]




Work Item Status:
Date Initiated:03-20-2013
Technical Contact: Kenneth Orie

Item: 001
Ballot: A01.11 (13-02)
Status: Negative Votes Need Resolution

Standards Tracker

Standards Subscriptions