ASTM WK40501

    Revision of D3939 / D3939M - 11 Standard Test Method for Snagging Resistance of Fabrics (Mace)

    (What is a Work Item?)

    Active Standard: D3939 / D3939M - 13

    Developed by Subcommittee: D13.59 | Committee D13 | Contact Staff Manager


    1. Rationale

    In test methods, D3939, D5362, and D5430, there was a specification for using a particular fluorescent bulb with a specific color temperature as a light source for the visual grading of fabric samples. This specification was questioned by Subcommittee D13.59. Since there was no compelling evidence to the contrary, a change in the wording of the specification of the light source to eliminate the nature of the light bulb and its color temperature was balloted. One subcommittee member expressed a negative concerning the change and insisted that the color temperature was critical. We initiated a study to test this hypothesis by assembling a series of fabric samples, which had been subjected to snagging, and several operators graded these samples using 6 different light sources. Since the analysis by ILS (#690)confirms the data analysis performed by James Knopp, which was presented in the June 2012 committee meeting, there is no effect of the nature of the light source and its color temperature on the ability to grade fabric samples.


    knitted fabric; snagging resistance; woven fabric; Mace test method; Man-made textile fibers; Snagging resistance; Nonwoven textile fabrics; Textile fabrics (general); Yarn properties;
    Citing ASTM Standards
    Back to Top
    Work Item Status

    Date Initiated:

    Technical Contact:
    James Knopp

    Draft Under Development